Tuesday, April 15, 2008

Affirming the Consequent


when i go home sometime I am alone by that I mean none of my home mates are in the house and sometimes they both are inside so I am not alone.





  • If they are not inside they are outside.

  • They are outside

  • Therefore, they are not inside.

The above argument may be valid, but only if the claim "if he's outside, then he's not inside" follows from the first premise. Even in such a case, however, the validity stems not from affirming the consequent, but from the form modus ponens.

No comments: